Page 1 of 1

Using knife tool converts all contours to quadratic

Posted: Sat Jul 07, 2018 5:13 am
by nabsltd
In FontCreator 11.5.0.2427 (64-bit):

Using the knife tool to cut any contour in a glyph results in all the contours in the glyph being converted to quadratic. Since this can result in a change in the contours, it is not desired behavior.

In addition, it can also result in an exported font not being truly validated. This can happen because the quadratic contours in the glyph need to be converted to cubic for export (assuming they were cubic in the first place because it was a font with PostScript outlines). If the user doesn't notice and manually change the contours to cubic, they can have validated quadratic outlines in the glyph, and the glyph in the exported font can have points that don't pass validation, but the user will never know if they only work with the FontCreator project file (.fcp), and don't open and validate the exported font.

Re: Using knife tool converts all contours to quadratic

Posted: Mon Jul 16, 2018 6:28 am
by nabsltd
It looks like almost any manipulation of contours that might change the number of contours (knife, union, intersection, exclusion) will cause any contours selected at the time of the operation to convert from cubic to quadratic, even if the contours are not changed by the operation.

For example, draw a rectangle in an empty glyph, then do a "union" operation. Regardless of the type of contour before the union, after the union it will be quadratic, even though there was no need to change anything to take the "union".

Re: Using knife tool converts all contours to quadratic

Posted: Wed Aug 07, 2019 5:44 pm
by janndk
Anything new about this?

Re: Using knife tool converts all contours to quadratic

Posted: Wed Aug 07, 2019 6:10 pm
by Bhikkhu Pesala
No change in FontCreator 12.

Re: Using knife tool converts all contours to quadratic

Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 1:41 pm
by janndk
Hmm... FontCreator manual says:

"Note: Union, Intersection, Exclusion and Knife only work with contours made out of quadratic B├ęzier curves. If you use them with cubic curves, FontCreator will convert those contours to quadratic."

So this behavior seems to be intended, and not a bug. However, it's quite annoying when curve type suddenly changes :?